In This Article
Battle at a Glance
The Yost Post · Battlefield Dossier
Battle of Paulus Hook
August 19, 1779 · Paulus Hook, New Jersey
Before dawn on August 19, 1779, Major Henry Lee led a selected American force against the British garrison at Paulus Hook, a fortified peninsula on the New Jersey shore opposite Manhattan. The operation depended on secrecy, a difficult nighttime approach across marshy ground, and a rapid attack before British reinforcements could cross the Hudson River.
American troops penetrated the principal defenses and captured a substantial number of British and Loyalist soldiers. However, a separate defensive position under Major William Sutherland remained in British hands. With daylight approaching and the possibility of reinforcement increasing, Lee withdrew with his prisoners rather than attempting to hold the post.
- Date
- August 19, 1779
- Location
- Paulus Hook, Bergen County, New Jersey, in 1779
- Present-Day Location
- Jersey City, Hudson County, New Jersey
- Campaign
- 1779 operations around British-occupied New York
- American Commander
- Major Henry Lee
- British Commander
- Major William Sutherland
- American Forces
- Selected Continental infantry and men of Lee’s partisan corps
- British Forces
- British regulars and Loyalist troops
- American Strength
- Approximately 300–400 in commonly cited estimates
- British Garrison
- Several hundred; precise effective strength varies by account
- Type of Engagement
- Nighttime raid and surprise assault
- Result
- American tactical victory; British retained the post
American Objective
Surprise the British garrison, capture prisoners and military supplies where practicable, disrupt British control of the New Jersey waterfront, and withdraw before reinforcements arrived.
British Objective
Protect the Paulus Hook outpost, preserve communications with Manhattan, secure the waterfront, and prevent American troops from penetrating the defenses.
Decisive factors: Surprise, nighttime movement, British vulnerability outside the strongest redoubt, American discipline during the assault, and Lee’s decision to withdraw before British reinforcements could intervene.
The figure of approximately 158 prisoners is widely cited. British casualty totals are less consistent, and some summaries combine killed, wounded, and prisoners differently. The numbers should not be treated as a complete contemporary return without checking the original reports.
Historical Background
British Occupation of New York City
After capturing New York City in 1776, British forces established a major military and naval base on Manhattan and the surrounding islands. The occupation allowed Britain to control important waterways and support operations throughout the middle colonies.
The New Jersey Shore
The western shore of the Hudson River remained contested. British outposts protected crossings and communications, while American forces operated farther inland and periodically threatened exposed positions.
Paulus Hook’s Strategic Importance
Paulus Hook was a projecting area of land on the Hudson River opposite lower Manhattan. Its waterfront position supported ferries, military transport, and communication between New York and New Jersey.
British Fortification of the Hook
The British constructed defensive works, including redoubts, entrenchments, and obstacles protecting the landward approaches. Surrounding tidal marshes made the position difficult to attack during daylight.
American Operations in 1779
Washington’s army could not easily dislodge the main British force from New York. Instead, American commanders sought opportunities to attack isolated outposts and impose costs without committing to a general battle.
The Battle of Stony Point
On July 16, 1779, Anthony Wayne’s troops captured the British position at Stony Point in a nighttime assault. The operation demonstrated the value of carefully planned attacks against fortified outposts.
Henry Lee’s Partisan Operations
Major Henry Lee commanded a mobile Continental force known for reconnaissance, raids, and rapid movement. His troops operated in the contested territory surrounding the British occupation zone.
The Opportunity at Paulus Hook
Lee identified the garrison as a possible target. Its proximity to Manhattan made an attack dangerous, but the surrounding marshes and reliance on fixed defenses also created opportunities for surprise.
Washington’s Approval
Lee submitted his proposed operation to George Washington. Washington authorized the attempt while emphasizing the importance of avoiding unnecessary losses and ensuring a secure withdrawal.
The American Objective
The intended operation was a raid, not a permanent occupation. Its success would be measured by surprise, prisoners taken, damage inflicted, and the safe return of the attacking force.
Commanders & Participating Forces
American Command
| Commander or Formation | Organization | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Major Henry Lee | Continental Army partisan corps | Overall raid commander |
| Lee’s Legion / partisan corps | Continental light troops | Reconnaissance, guidance, and assault support |
| Selected Continental infantry | Detached infantry from Washington’s army | Principal attacking force |
| American supporting detachments | Continental troops assigned to the operation | Security, support, and withdrawal |
Major Henry Lee
Henry Lee, later widely known as Light-Horse Harry Lee, was an experienced cavalry and partisan officer. At Paulus Hook, he directed an infantry-heavy raid requiring stealth and careful timing rather than a mounted charge.
Lee’s Corps
Lee’s command was a specialized Continental formation used for reconnaissance and mobile operations. Its organization evolved during the war. Researchers should use the unit’s designation as recorded in 1779 rather than automatically applying later organizational titles to every participant.
Selected Continental Infantry
The attacking force included infantry detached from Continental formations. These soldiers provided the manpower needed to storm the British defenses and secure prisoners.
British Command
| Commander or Formation | Organization | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Major William Sutherland | British garrison | Senior officer associated with the defense |
| British regular infantry | British Army | Defended the fortified post |
| Loyalist soldiers | Provincial and British-aligned troops | Garrison duties and defense |
| British forces in Manhattan | New York occupation army | Potential reinforcements across the Hudson |
Major William Sutherland
Sutherland commanded part of the British defense and remained in a fortified position that the Americans did not capture. His resistance prevented Lee from claiming possession of the entire complex.
The British Garrison
The garrison included regular and Loyalist personnel assigned to defend the post and maintain British control of the waterfront. Precise regimental participation should be verified against British returns rather than inferred from the general composition of the New York garrison.
Strength Estimates
Many histories estimate Lee’s force at approximately 300–400 men. Estimates of the British garrison also vary, partly because not all personnel were in the same defensive positions when the raid began.
Paulus Hook involved a specially assembled American raiding force. Service in a parent Continental regiment does not prove that a particular soldier joined Lee’s expedition. The same caution applies to British units stationed in the New York area: only men assigned to Paulus Hook at the relevant date should be treated as garrison participants.
Battlefield Geography & Terrain
The Hudson River
The Hudson separated Paulus Hook from British-held Manhattan. This proximity allowed rapid British communication and potential reinforcement but also made the outpost strategically valuable.
The Original Peninsula
In 1779, Paulus Hook was a projecting peninsula bordered by tidal waters and marshes. Extensive later filling and urban development have substantially altered the original shoreline.
The Landward Approach
The principal overland approach crossed low, wet ground. An attacking force had to negotiate marshes, waterways, and defensive obstacles before reaching the fortifications.
Tidal Conditions
The depth and passability of marsh channels changed with the tide. Lee’s operation depended on moving men across terrain that could become difficult or dangerous when water levels changed.
British Redoubts
The defensive complex included separate fortified positions. This arrangement meant that penetrating one part of the post did not automatically neutralize every British defender.
Entrenchments and Obstacles
Earthworks and obstacles protected the British from a direct approach. They were more difficult to overcome in daylight, when defenders could observe movement across the marshes.
The Manhattan Waterfront
British forces across the Hudson represented a constant threat to the Americans. The attackers had limited time before alarm signals or messengers could bring reinforcements.
The American Withdrawal Route
Lee needed a route away from the peninsula and back toward American-held territory. Captured prisoners increased the size and reduced the speed of the withdrawing column.
Paulus Hook Today
The battlefield lies within the modern urban landscape of Jersey City. Streets, buildings, and reclaimed land obscure much of the eighteenth-century geography.
Historical Map Interpretation
Modern maps should not be used to reconstruct the assault without reference to eighteenth-century shoreline and fortification plans. The original marshes and water boundaries were central to the operation.
Paulus Hook’s tidal marshes made the British position difficult to approach, but they also helped conceal Lee’s movement during darkness. The Americans accepted the risk of crossing wet, broken ground in exchange for surprise. The separate British redoubts and proximity to Manhattan limited how long Lee could remain after penetrating the defenses.
Weapons, Equipment & Logistics
Continental Infantry Weapons
American troops carried flintlock muskets and bayonets. The raid emphasized rapid movement and close assault rather than prolonged exchanges of fire.
Lee’s Partisan Equipment
Men of Lee’s corps were accustomed to mobile operations. For Paulus Hook, the mission required moving through marshland and fighting in confined defensive positions.
British Garrison Weapons
The defenders possessed standard infantry firearms and weapons associated with a fortified outpost. British troops were better positioned for sustained defense once the alarm was raised.
Bayonets
Bayonets were important to the assault because they allowed soldiers to overwhelm defenders at close quarters without relying exclusively on musket fire.
Ammunition
The Americans carried ammunition for a limited operation. They did not intend to sustain a long siege or fight a prolonged battle against reinforcements from Manhattan.
Artillery and Fortification
British defensive works included artillery positions. Lee’s force did not bring the heavy equipment required to reduce every fortified work through a conventional siege.
Night Navigation
Movement depended on guides, officers, and maintaining contact between detachments. Darkness and wet terrain made it difficult to preserve formation.
Prisoner Movement
Capturing prisoners created an immediate logistical challenge. Guards had to secure the captives and move them away from the fort before British reinforcements arrived.
Food and Fatigue
The raiders undertook a demanding night march followed by combat and withdrawal. Their endurance was a significant factor in completing the operation.
Medical Support
The limited duration of the raid left little opportunity for elaborate medical arrangements. Wounded men had to be removed while the force remained under threat of pursuit.
Intelligence & Operational Planning
Identification of the Target
Lee selected Paulus Hook because it was an exposed British post whose defenses might be penetrated by a carefully timed nighttime attack.
Reconnaissance
Information about the garrison, approaches, and surrounding terrain was essential. Lee needed to know how his men could cross the marshes and reach the defensive works without being discovered.
Washington’s Authorization
Washington approved the raid while cautioning against an operation that might expose the troops to unnecessary destruction.
Assembly of the Raiding Force
Lee drew together selected soldiers from Continental formations and his own command. The resulting force was intended for a short, coordinated attack.
The Night March
The Americans advanced toward Paulus Hook during the night of August 18–19. Their movement required navigating difficult terrain while maintaining secrecy.
Loss of Direction and Delay
Accounts describe navigational difficulties during the approach. The Americans nevertheless reached the British position before daylight.
Approach Through the Marshes
The raiders crossed wet ground and tidal approaches surrounding the post. The terrain complicated movement but also reduced the likelihood of detection.
Surprise at the Defenses
American troops penetrated British positions before the defenders could organize a complete response.
Capture of Prisoners
The attackers overwhelmed portions of the garrison and secured numerous prisoners.
Sutherland’s Resistance
Major Sutherland held a separate fortified position. Lee lacked sufficient time to reduce it without risking the entire expedition.
The Withdrawal Decision
Lee ordered his men to leave with their prisoners. Remaining at Paulus Hook after daylight would have exposed the Americans to counterattack and reinforcement from Manhattan.
Return to American Lines
The force withdrew through New Jersey. Despite the difficulties of the operation, Lee brought back a substantial body of prisoners.
Lee’s raid succeeded because its objective was limited and its timing carefully chosen. Surprise allowed the Americans to capture part of the British position, but the surviving redoubt and nearby British reinforcements made prolonged occupation impractical. Lee’s withdrawal preserved the force and converted the temporary penetration of the defenses into a successful raid.
Battle of Paulus Hook: Interactive Timeline
Strategic Background
1776 — British capture New York City
British forces establish their principal military base in New York and occupy strategic positions along the Hudson River.
1777–1779 — Paulus Hook fortified
The British maintain defenses on the New Jersey waterfront opposite Manhattan.
July 16, 1779 — Battle of Stony Point
Anthony Wayne’s Continental troops capture a British outpost in a successful nighttime assault.
Summer 1779 — Lee plans a raid
Henry Lee identifies Paulus Hook as a target and develops a plan for a surprise attack.
Washington authorizes the operation
George Washington approves Lee’s proposed raid while emphasizing the need to preserve the troops.
August 18: The Approach
Evening — American force begins its march
Lee’s selected troops move toward the British post under cover of darkness.
Night — Difficult navigation
The Americans encounter delays and navigational problems during their approach.
Late night — Raiders enter the marshes
American troops move across wet ground and tidal approaches toward Paulus Hook.
August 19: The Battle
Before dawn — Americans reach British defenses
The attacking force approaches the fortified post while much of the garrison remains unprepared for an assault.
Surprise attack begins
Lee’s troops penetrate the defenses and overwhelm British personnel in parts of the complex.
British prisoners captured
American troops secure numerous defenders, eventually withdrawing with approximately 158 prisoners according to commonly cited accounts.
Sutherland holds a separate redoubt
Major William Sutherland maintains resistance in a position that the Americans do not capture.
Lee decides against further assault
With daylight approaching and reinforcements possible, Lee determines that remaining at the post would be too dangerous.
Americans withdraw from Paulus Hook
The raiders leave with prisoners rather than attempting to occupy the fortifications.
American column moves inland
Lee leads his men and captives away from the British position.
Aftermath
August 1779 — Washington receives Lee’s report
Washington learns of the raid and its results.
1779 — Congressional recognition
Congress honors Lee for his conduct in the operation.
September 1779 — Lee’s conduct examined
A court-martial considers accusations relating to the raid; Lee is acquitted.
Later war years — British retain New York
The British continue occupying New York City and associated positions until the end of the war.
Tactical Analysis & Command Decisions
Phase One: Selecting an Exposed Outpost
Lee chose a British position that was valuable but vulnerable to a short, carefully executed raid. He did not attempt to challenge the main British army in New York.
Phase Two: Concentrating a Selected Force
The Americans assembled a relatively small body of experienced troops capable of marching at night and conducting a close assault.
Phase Three: Crossing Difficult Terrain
The marshes surrounding Paulus Hook delayed the Americans but concealed their approach. The operation required balancing secrecy against the danger of becoming trapped by the tide or losing direction.
Phase Four: Achieving Surprise
American troops reached the defenses before the garrison could fully organize. Surprise reduced the advantage normally enjoyed by soldiers defending prepared works.
Phase Five: Penetrating the Position
The raiders overwhelmed part of the garrison and captured prisoners. The initial assault succeeded without the need for a prolonged siege.
Phase Six: Sutherland’s Redoubt
The survival of a separate British defensive position prevented Lee from controlling the entire complex. A further attack would have consumed time and risked additional casualties.
Phase Seven: The Reinforcement Threat
British troops in Manhattan could cross the Hudson to assist the garrison. The approaching daylight increased the danger of remaining at Paulus Hook.
Phase Eight: Withdrawal with Prisoners
Lee withdrew rather than attempt to occupy the post. Escorting prisoners complicated movement, but the Americans retained their principal gains.
Why Lee Succeeded
The raid used secrecy, limited objectives, selected troops, and a disciplined withdrawal. Lee understood that the operation did not require permanent possession of the fort.
Why the British Were Surprised
The garrison relied on marshes, obstacles, and fortifications to protect the post. Lee exploited the expectation that these approaches would be difficult to cross undetected.
Why the British Retained Paulus Hook
Sutherland’s resistance and the nearby British army made continued American occupation impractical. Lee withdrew before the British could concentrate against him.
Comparison with Stony Point
Both Paulus Hook and Stony Point involved American nighttime attacks against British outposts in 1779. At Stony Point, Wayne’s force captured the principal position. At Paulus Hook, Lee penetrated part of the defenses and withdrew with prisoners while the British retained the overall post.
Paulus Hook was a successful raid rather than a territorial conquest. Lee’s force overcame difficult approaches, surprised the defenders, and captured prisoners while avoiding destruction by the much larger British army nearby. The decision to withdraw was consistent with the operation’s limited purpose, although the incomplete capture of the defensive complex later contributed to controversy over Lee’s conduct.
The Soldier’s Experience
The Night March
American soldiers marched through darkness toward a British post located close to the enemy’s principal military base. Maintaining silence and formation was essential to the mission.
Wet and Difficult Ground
The approach required movement through marshes and tidal ground. Soldiers risked losing their footing, becoming separated, or making enough noise to alert the defenders.
Limited Visibility
Darkness made it difficult to identify terrain features and maintain contact with neighboring detachments. Officers and guides played an important role in keeping the column together.
The Moment of Assault
Once the Americans reached the defenses, the operation changed rapidly from a concealed march to close combat. Soldiers had to follow orders quickly while entering unfamiliar fortifications.
British Garrison Soldiers
Defenders surprised during the attack had little time to assemble into organized formations. Men in separate defensive positions experienced the battle differently.
Capture and Surrender
American troops disarmed and secured British prisoners. The captives then had to be escorted out of the fortified position before reinforcements arrived.
Fighting Around the Redoubts
The existence of separate defensive works meant that combat did not occur uniformly across the post. Some British personnel surrendered while others continued resisting.
The Withdrawal
After the attack, American soldiers retraced their route with prisoners. The return march required continued discipline because the British could still pursue or intercept the column.
Fatigue
The operation combined nighttime marching, difficult terrain, combat, and withdrawal. Even men who escaped injury faced considerable physical exhaustion.
The Meaning of the Raid
For the participating Americans, the raid demonstrated that the British occupation perimeter could be penetrated. For British defenders, it revealed the vulnerability of a fortified post despite its proximity to Manhattan.
Where Was Your Ancestor’s Unit?
The Battle of Paulus Hook is particularly relevant to research on Henry Lee’s Continental partisan corps, selected Continental infantry detachments, British regulars stationed on the New Jersey waterfront, and Loyalist troops serving around New York City.
| Formation or Research Group | Battlefield Connection | Recommended Records |
|---|---|---|
| Henry Lee’s partisan corps | American raid leadership and assault support | Continental Army muster rolls and Lee correspondence |
| Selected Continental infantry | Main attacking force | Detachment orders, regimental returns, and pension files |
| American supporting troops | Approach and withdrawal | Washington’s orders and campaign correspondence |
| British garrison at Paulus Hook | Defense of the outpost | British muster books and garrison returns |
| William Sutherland’s command | Defense of surviving redoubt | British military correspondence |
| Loyalist troops | British-aligned garrison service | Provincial military records and Loyalist claims |
| British reinforcements from New York | Potential response to raid | New York garrison orders and naval correspondence |
Lee’s Corps
Research should begin with the unit’s 1779 organization and service records. Its later name, Lee’s Legion, is widely recognized, but individual records may use earlier or different designations.
Continental Infantry Detachments
Lee’s raiding force included selected infantry rather than every man of the participating parent regiments. A regimental history alone cannot prove an individual’s presence.
Officer Correspondence
Henry Lee’s reports and Washington’s correspondence can help establish which detachments were assigned to the operation.
Revolutionary War Pension Applications
Veterans may refer to Paulus Hook, Powles Hook, Paulis Hook, service under Major Lee, or an attack near New York City in August 1779.
British Muster Books
British garrison records can identify soldiers assigned to Paulus Hook during the raid. Researchers should distinguish the outpost garrison from units stationed elsewhere in New York.
Loyalist Records
Loyalist soldiers may appear in provincial military records, compensation claims, and later settlement documents in British North America.
Historical Place Names
Paulus Hook appears under variant spellings in historical documents. Searching only the modern name may omit relevant records.
New Jersey County Boundaries
The battlefield was in Bergen County in 1779. It is now in Hudson County, which was established later. Genealogical research should use the correct jurisdiction for the date of the record.
Research Cautions
Do not assume all members of Lee’s parent formation took part in the raid.
Do not equate every British soldier stationed in New York with a Paulus Hook defender.
Do not treat the approximately 158 prisoners as a complete roster of the British garrison.
Do not confuse the 1779 peninsula with the substantially altered modern shoreline.
Establish the soldier’s company, regiment or corps, service dates, and detachment assignment. Compare muster rolls, officer correspondence, pension declarations, and British garrison returns. The most important distinction is between documented participation in the August 19 raid and general service in the New York–New Jersey theater during 1779.
Battle Outcome & Casualties
American Tactical Victory
Lee’s force surprised the garrison, captured prisoners, and withdrew. The Americans achieved the principal purpose of a limited raid.
British Retention of the Post
The British retained Paulus Hook after the Americans departed. The raid did not result in permanent American control of the peninsula.
American Casualties
Commonly cited accounts report two Americans killed and three wounded. Other records should be consulted before treating those numbers as a definitive complete return.
British Prisoners
Approximately 158 British and Loyalist personnel were captured according to frequently cited summaries.
British Killed and Wounded
Published figures vary, with some accounts reporting dozens of additional casualties. The exact totals depend on which reports and categories are used.
| Category | American Forces | British Forces |
|---|---|---|
| Principal Commander | Henry Lee | William Sutherland |
| Estimated Strength | Approximately 300–400 | Several hundred |
| Killed | Commonly reported as 2 | Disputed |
| Wounded | Commonly reported as 3 | Disputed |
| Prisoners Taken | Approximately 158 captured | Approximately 158 lost as prisoners |
| Fortifications | Penetrated but not retained | Partially overrun; remaining defenses held |
| Result | Successful raid | Post retained |
Military Supplies
The Americans did not conduct a prolonged occupation or comprehensive removal of the post’s artillery and stores. The principal measurable gain was the capture of prisoners.
Operational Result
The raid embarrassed the British command and demonstrated American offensive capability near Manhattan without materially changing control of the Hudson waterfront.
Casualty Accounting
Researchers should distinguish prisoners captured during the assault from killed and wounded, and should compare Lee’s reports with British records when calculating losses.
Strategic Aftermath
Washington’s Reaction
Washington recognized the value of Lee’s success while remaining concerned with the risks and execution of operations against British outposts.
Congressional Recognition
Congress awarded Henry Lee a gold medal for the operation, an important distinction for an American officer during the Revolutionary War.
Controversy Over the Raid
Lee’s conduct was later challenged, including questions concerning aspects of the operation and its execution. A court-martial acquitted him.
British Defensive Concerns
The raid demonstrated that the British occupation perimeter was vulnerable to surprise attacks even close to the main base in New York City.
The Relationship to Stony Point
Paulus Hook followed the American victory at Stony Point by approximately one month. Both operations reflected Washington’s willingness to authorize limited attacks against exposed British positions.
Limited Territorial Consequences
The British remained in control of Paulus Hook and New York City. The Americans did not attempt to transform the raid into a larger campaign to seize the waterfront.
Henry Lee’s Military Reputation
The operation strengthened Lee’s reputation as a capable commander of mobile troops and contributed to his later prominence in the Revolutionary War.
Lee’s Later Service
Lee subsequently served in the southern campaigns, where his mounted and dismounted troops conducted reconnaissance, raids, and combat operations.
The End of British Occupation
British forces continued occupying New York City until 1783. The eventual evacuation followed the wider conclusion of the war rather than a direct consequence of the Paulus Hook raid.
Modern Commemoration
The battle is commemorated in Jersey City, where monuments and historical interpretation preserve the memory of the raid despite extensive changes to the original landscape.
The Battle’s Larger Significance
Paulus Hook demonstrated that small, well-led Continental forces could conduct successful offensive operations against fortified British positions without committing to a major battle. Its success rested on surprise, disciplined execution, and withdrawal before enemy reinforcements could arrive.
Primary Sources & Historical Research
The Battle of Paulus Hook is documented through correspondence involving Henry Lee and George Washington, Continental Army records, congressional proceedings, British military reports, and later historical studies. These sources are especially valuable for reconstructing the raid’s objectives, the American route, the prisoners captured, and the decision to withdraw.
Primary and Early Historical Sources
- Henry Lee’s Reports, August 1779. Accounts of the raid, captured prisoners, and withdrawal.
- George Washington’s Correspondence, August 1779. Planning, authorization, and assessment of the operation.
- Continental Army Orders and Returns. Documentation concerning the participating detachments.
- British Garrison Correspondence. Reports concerning the attack and defense of Paulus Hook.
- Continental Congress Journals. Congressional recognition of Henry Lee’s conduct.
- Henry Lee, Memoirs of the War in the Southern Department of the United States. Later reflections by the American commander.
- William S. Stryker, The Battle of Paulus Hook. Historical treatment of the raid and its participants.
Historical Research Resources
- Founders Online — National Archives. Washington and Lee correspondence concerning the 1779 operation. Search the correspondence.
- George Washington’s Mount Vernon. Washington’s military leadership and Revolutionary War operations. Explore Washington’s military history.
- American Battlefield Trust. Research on Revolutionary War engagements and the New York–New Jersey campaigns. Explore battlefield research.
- New Jersey State Archives. Revolutionary War military, civil, and genealogical records. Research New Jersey records.
- New Jersey Historical Commission. State historical resources and research. Explore New Jersey history.
- National Archives — Revolutionary War Records. Continental Army service and pension documentation. Research military service.
- Library of Congress. Historical maps, manuscripts, newspapers, and published histories of Paulus Hook. Search historical collections.
- The National Archives, United Kingdom. British Army records, correspondence, and garrison returns. Search British military records.
- Jersey City Historical Resources. Local records concerning Paulus Hook, its fortifications, and the changing waterfront.
- New Jersey Revolutionary War Heritage Resources. Historical interpretation of the state’s wartime sites and military operations.
Historical Research Cautions
Battle date: August 19, 1779.
Location: Paulus Hook, present-day Jersey City, New Jersey.
Historical county: Bergen County in 1779; Hudson County today.
American commander: Major Henry Lee.
British commander: Major William Sutherland.
Type of operation: Nighttime raid.
Result: American tactical victory; British retained the post.
Historical caution: The Americans penetrated portions of the British defenses but did not capture every redoubt.
Historical caution: The raid did not establish permanent American control of Paulus Hook.
Historical caution: Henry Lee’s force included selected Continental infantry and men from his own corps.
Historical caution: Troop-strength estimates vary among published accounts.
Historical caution: Approximately 158 British prisoners is a commonly reported figure, but detailed casualty categories should be checked against original returns.
Historical caution: The eighteenth-century shoreline differs substantially from the modern Jersey City waterfront.
Historical caution: The battle should not be confused with the earlier capture of Paulus Hook by British forces during the New York campaign.
Genealogical caution: Service in a participating parent regiment does not independently prove that a soldier joined Lee’s raiding detachment.
The Battle of Paulus Hook on August 19, 1779, was a successful American raid against a British fortified outpost opposite Manhattan. Major Henry Lee led selected Continental troops through difficult marshland approaches during the night and surprised portions of the British garrison. The Americans penetrated the defenses and captured approximately 158 prisoners, but a separate position under Major William Sutherland continued resisting. With daylight approaching and British reinforcements available across the Hudson River, Lee withdrew rather than attempt to occupy the entire complex. The British retained Paulus Hook, but the raid demonstrated American capability to strike exposed positions near New York City. Its success contributed to Lee’s military reputation and earned him a congressional gold medal.